Skip to content
← Back to the blog

Swapping jigsaw puzzles: the piece from another box

Beatriz finishes a borrowed jigsaw and finds a piece from a different picture. Returning it seems a tiny errand, until other boxes start joining the search.

BarbellPin ·

The piece has a red stripe and a patch of sky. Beatriz turns it on the table, holds it beside the lid, then turns it again. The finished jigsaw shows a market stall: boxes of oranges, a green awning, people carrying shopping bags. There isn't a red stripe anywhere near that spot. There isn't an empty space either. The picture is complete, with one piece left over.

Her partner, Nico, suggests putting it back in the box. “It arrived there. Let it keep travelling.” Beatriz doesn't want the next person to spend an afternoon looking for a bit of awning that doesn't exist. She doesn't want to keep something that might belong to someone else's picture, either. She puts it in an empty mug and takes a photograph before dismantling the oranges.

For two months she's been swapping jigsaws at a small neighbourhood centre. She takes one, leaves another and writes the date on a sheet. Some boxes look almost new; others have corners held together with tape. The market came with a slip saying “Complete. Checked by Carmen.” Beatriz recognises the handwriting. Carmen writes the shelf labels too.

Blue cardboard jigsaw pieces on a white background

Blue cardboard jigsaw pieces on a white background. Photo: Ksenia Pixelesse, Unsplash. License Unsplash.

A mug holding just one thing

On Saturday she takes back the box, with the spare piece in an envelope. Carmen looks first at the photograph of the completed market. Then she holds the piece up near the window. She thinks it could show a parasol. Beatriz sees a tower. For a minute they discuss it with the seriousness of people identifying something washed up at sea.

Seven boxes are waiting to be checked. They stand them on their sides across a table and compare the lids: a mountain landscape, cats among books, a harbour at sunset. The harbour has a red and white lighthouse. Beatriz holds up the piece, but the picture is too small to be sure. Carmen goes to find the borrowing sheet.

The harbour came back last week. Luis had borrowed it; he usually comes on Wednesdays. The sheet doesn't have users' phone numbers on display, and Beatriz doesn't ask for them. Carmen, who coordinates the swap, offers to ask him when he comes in. The piece can stay in its envelope. Beatriz writes what they know on the outside: “Found in Market. Possible lighthouse.”

She goes home without an answer and with a jigsaw showing railway stations. Nico asks whether they've solved the mystery. She says no and puts the new box on a shelf. That afternoon they find an hour to open it. Without discussing it, they divide up the edges, then combine their piles when one of them realises he's also collected straight lines from the platform.

A piece in the middle of the table seems to fit three places. Beatriz thinks of the envelope. Until now, whenever she couldn't find something, she'd searched her own piles. The idea of a missing piece sitting in another house feels both annoying and funny. Nico says that if one is missing, they'll wait to see where the gap ends up.

The lighthouse wasn't missing anything

On Thursday, Carmen sends a message through the channel they use for swap notices. Luis has seen the piece. His harbour is complete. He brought a photograph to show them, although nobody asked him to prove it. He thinks the red stripe belongs to a boat in another box. Beatriz studies the picture on her phone. Now it looks like a boat to her as well.

She tells Nico over dinner at the free end of their table. The new jigsaw covers the rest. They've left space for two plates and a jug, but every time somebody moves the bread, a piece appears underneath. Beatriz lifts the basket and discovers a blue window. She puts it beside the station before that one starts travelling too.

On Saturday she returns to the centre. Luis is there with a thin folder containing photographs of finished puzzles, printed on ordinary paper. He isn't keeping a record to show off how fast he works. He likes remembering who lent him each box and when he returned it. One picture includes half a kitchen table, a salt shaker and his brother's arm resting on a chair.

Beatriz recognises an illustrated street she assembled in January, before discovering the swap. Luis points to a cat coming out of a window. She never noticed it. She spent three afternoons looking at that picture and remembers the bakery window perfectly because it held her up for ages. The cat was a few centimetres away. They laugh at how differently two people can visit the same image.

Jigsaw pieces on a wooden table

Jigsaw pieces on a wooden table. Photo: Joseph Malone, Unsplash. License Unsplash.

A box could carry on travelling

Carmen finds a box showing houses beside a canal. One chimney has a red stripe. The piece isn't from that one either: the puzzle has a white backing, while the cardboard in the envelope is grey underneath. Three possibilities have now been crossed out. Beatriz is enjoying the conversation, but worries that one loose piece is becoming a job for the entire neighbourhood.

She suggests leaving it somewhere visible with the photograph and a short description. Carmen makes room in a folder used for swap notices. They won't stick anything to the boxes or add the piece to the next loan. They won't label a checked, complete puzzle “incomplete”, either. The question can stay open without holding up everything else.

Before leaving, Beatriz helps clear the table. Luis separates the checked boxes from those still waiting, and Carmen records two returns. The piece goes back into its envelope. This takes five minutes and is easier than imagining more lighthouses. It also frees the table for the group coming in afterwards to play dominoes. They can carry on without solving everything first.

At home she finishes the station with Nico. No pieces are missing. He takes a photograph from a chair to get the entire image in; their two plates appear in one corner. Beatriz saves it beside the market picture. Next time she'll include a photograph and a short note with the box, without turning every exchange into a case file.

Three weeks later, Carmen recognises the stripe on a box that has just arrived. It's part of a deckchair in a beach scene. The person returning it mentions a gap beside the parasol. They try the piece, and it fits. Carmen sends a photograph of the reunion. Beatriz shows Nico. They had both been quite close, and completely wrong.

That Sunday she leaves the next jigsaw unopened until the afternoon and goes to the gym. In BarbellPin she opens Workout, chooses a saved routine and confirms to start a new session, as explained in the workout guide. Back home, she opens the box on the cleared table and puts the lid where they can see it. Nico finds somewhere else for the bread.

A man training with two dumbbells in a dark gym

A man training with two dumbbells in a dark gym. Photo: foad shariyati, Pexels. License Pexels.

Download BarbellPin