Skip to content
← Back to the blog

Interviewing someone for the first time: the candidate's question

Sergio is interviewing a potential colleague. He has twelve questions ready, but the one that changes the conversation isn't on his sheet.

BarbellPin ·

Sergio tries both chairs before deciding where to sit. One backrest makes a noise whenever he moves; the other chair faces away from the door. He takes the noisy one and leaves the good one for the visitor. His first interview as an interviewer starts in ten minutes, and he has already spent three of them on the furniture.

He schedules repair visits for a small company. He takes requests, checks what equipment is needed and assigns jobs to the technicians. Now they want someone to share that desk. His manager, Pilar, will cover employment terms and the hiring process. Sergio will explain the work and ask about situations the candidate has handled. When he agreed, it sounded straightforward. He does this work every day.

The previous evening he searched for interview questions and filled a page. Strengths, difficulties, a problem that needed solving. He read the sentences aloud over dinner and replaced “competencies” with “things you know how to do”. They still sounded borrowed. At the bottom he wrote his own question about two urgent repairs arriving at once.

Office with work desks and chairs

Office with work desks and chairs. Photo: The Yardcoworking, Unsplash. Unsplash License.

The page he could barely look away from

The candidate is called Iván and arrives with a small notebook. He asks whether he can leave his coat on a spare chair. Sergio answers too quickly, then explains his role in the conversation, as agreed with Pilar. Knowing which part is his helps more than the list of twelve questions.

They begin with Iván's previous warehouse job. Sergio wants to know how he handled orders that changed after they had been prepared. Iván describes a return, briefly gets tangled in the names of two departments, then comes back to the problem. Sergio is about to move to question two when he realises he still doesn't know what Iván actually did. He asks. Iván spreads a hand on the table and goes through the sequence.

They discuss a delivery held up by a missing part. Iván had told the customer but hadn't told the colleague arranging transport. The package went out anyway. He also explains what he changed afterwards: before calling anyone outside, he checked who needed to stop the shipment inside. Sergio recognises a mistake that could happen at his own desk. He writes down that detail instead of “good communication”.

The chair creaks again. Iván smiles and Sergio explains why he chose it. For a few seconds they stop sounding like two people acting out an interview. Pilar asks about the urgent repairs example. Sergio reads his question, adding information when Iván asks for it: who is nearby, what tools they have and exactly what “urgent” means.

There isn't a single correct answer hidden underneath the paper. These are decisions Sergio makes daily and has never had to explain without pointing at a screen. He discovers that his question relies on several things he took for granted. He crosses out a word and notes which facts he must also give the next candidates.

“Who decides what can wait?”

When it's time for Iván's questions, Sergio starts putting away his pen. He expects a question about the software or working hours, which Pilar has already explained. Iván checks his notebook and asks what happens when a new job arrives and every technician is busy. Sergio says they rearrange the day.

“Yes, but who decides what can wait?” Iván asks.

Sergio looks at Pilar. He isn't asking permission to speak. He is trying to remember the last time they resolved that clearly. On Tuesday he moved a visit because he knew the customer. On Wednesday he left another decision to Pilar. On Thursday a technician called directly and changed the route. The advertisement said “independence in organising your work”.

He could repeat that sentence. Instead, he describes Thursday without names or customer details. He explains the technician's decision and which information reached the office too late. Pilar adds which decisions belong to her. Iván asks how a new person will know when to check with someone. That part doesn't yet have an answer as clear as the working hours.

Open notebook on a white desk beside a phone and laptop

Open notebook, phone and laptop on a white desk. Photo: JESHOOTS.COM, Unsplash. Unsplash License.

Sergio wants to promise it will all be sorted before the new person starts. Pilar says they need to make the arrangement clear and will send the information before the next stage. Iván writes something down. He doesn't look shocked. He wanted to know who to speak to when the phone rings and all three available options are bad.

They finish at the planned time. Pilar explains when they will be in touch, and Sergio walks Iván to the door. Back in the room, almost all twelve questions remain unused. But he has a page of notes he can understand: the situation Iván described, what he did and what still needs asking. He separates those observations from the things he needs to explain better himself.

Before lunch he returns to his desk and takes a call. The customer starts by saying his colleague already knows about it. Sergio finds the note but has to ask who confirmed the visit. It takes barely two minutes of his working day, too ordinary to have appeared in his description of the job. After hanging up, he writes the sequence on the back of his sheet. He can explain it without using a real customer case or leaving someone to guess which information is missing.

The job had questions to answer too

After lunch, Pilar and Sergio review their notes. They don't decide to hire someone because they liked a question he asked. There are other interviews to hold, and the agreed criteria remain the same. They review the experience required, the examples they heard and the remaining uncertainties. The conversation about assigning jobs goes on a separate list of work for the company.

On Friday they prepare a short sheet with three common situations and the person to consult in each. Sergio checks the examples with a technician. The technician points out an exception when a part is missing, even if there is time for the visit. They change that line. They also review the job description so they can explain “independence” without making it up as they go.

One hand writing in a notebook while the other uses a laptop keyboard

A hand writing in a notebook beside a laptop. Photo: MJ Duford, Unsplash. Unsplash License.

Before the next interview, Sergio chooses another room to get away from the ringing phone. He puts out water, rereads the application and leaves time for questions at the end. He no longer needs to fill every silence with another line from his list. He wants the other person to finish their account and leave knowing what work is actually on offer.

He plans to train that evening. In BarbellPin he opens Routines → Weekly plan, assigns an existing routine to a free slot and saves; the other slots can remain set to rest. The routine guide explains the plan. Then he closes his work diary. The noisy chair is still in the room, with a note asking someone to check it.

Man training with two dumbbells in a dark gym

Man holding two dumbbells beneath geometric lights. Photo: foad shariyati, Pexels. Pexels License.

Download BarbellPin